What are Anti Dilution Ratchets?

Anti-dilution ratchets are contractual measures intended to protect early investors from the dilution of their ownership stakes during subsequent funding rounds where new shares are issued at a lower price. These provisions adjust the price or conversion ratio of existing shares to reflect more favorable terms in response to new shares being sold at reduced prices, thereby preserving the value of the initial investment.

Types of Ratchet Provisions

Two primary forms of anti-dilution ratchet provisions exist:

• Full Ratchet: This type directly adjusts the existing shareholders' option prices or conversion ratios to match the price of the new shares, ensuring their ownership percentage remains unaffected regardless of how low the new share price is.
• Weighted Average Approach: This method provides a more moderate adjustment based on a weighted average price formula. It considers the number of new shares issued and their price, offering a less severe dilution effect than the full ratchet. It can be further divided into:
  • Narrow-Based: Only includes specific types of shares in its calculation.
  • Broad-Based: Incorporates all outstanding shares in its calculation, providing a fairer assessment across all shareholders.

Negotiating Ratchet Clauses

Negotiating these provisions requires a delicate balance between protecting the interests of early investors and maintaining the attractiveness of the company to future investors. Overly stringent anti-dilution measures, such as full ratchets, can deter new investment due to their harsh impact on new shareholders. Instead, a broad-based weighted-average provision might be a more equitable solution, as it balances the interests of all parties by proportionately distributing the effects of dilution.

Ratchet Impact on Shareholders

While full ratchet provisions can safeguard early investors against loss in share value due to subsequent cheaper share issues, they can also discourage new investors who might feel unfairly burdened by the aggressive dilution protection. This could potentially limit a company's ability to raise new capital. Weighted average provisions, being more balanced, tend to be more favorable in fostering an equitable investment environment.

Understanding Weighted Average Ratchets

Weighted average ratchets mitigate the potential harsh impacts of dilution on new investors, making them a popular choice. They adjust the conversion price based on a formula that considers both the number and price of new shares, thereby ensuring all shareholders bear a proportional share of the dilution. This approach can help maintain a healthier balance among the interests of existing investors, founders, and new shareholders.

In essence, the choice of anti-dilution provision has significant strategic implications for both the company’s fundraising efforts and its shareholder relations. It is important for companies to carefully consider which type of provision best aligns with their long-term financial strategy and investor relations.

‍